Yes, Virginia, There Is A Sh*tty First Draft

February 13, 2018 § 17 Comments

Sorry kid, we regret we’re unable to include your pony request in North Pole Review, please keep us in mind for future submissions

Interviewing an author for the Brevity Podcast, I ask how his book is coming along. He says it’s terrible. He has no idea how he’ll make his way through, finish a draft so he can fix it in revisions. I trust and respect this writer, but part of me still thinks, yeah, right. I know him to be an amazing writer, I love his work. I can’t imagine him writing the same pages of unfocused crap I do.

An early-career writer friend says, “Every time I read an interview with a famous author, they all say they write shitty first drafts. But they never show them to anyone, so it just sounds like something they say to make crappy writers feel better about themselves. Like telling us to believe in Santa Claus.”

The idea of the shitty first draft has been around for a long time. Ernest Hemingway: “The first draft of anything is shit.” Bernard Malamud: “The first draft of anything is suspect unless one is a genius.” Many of us know the concept from Anne Lamott’s Bird By Bird:

Shitty first drafts. All good writers write them. This is how they end up with good second drafts and terrific third drafts.

People tend to look at successful writers who are getting their books published and maybe even doing well financially and think that they sit down at their desks every morning feeling like a million dollars, feeling great about who they are and how much talent they have and what a great story they have to tell; that they take in a few deep breaths, push back their sleeves, roll their necks a few times to get all the cricks out, and dive in, typing fully formed passages as fast as a court reporter.

But this is just the fantasy of the uninitiated. I know some very great writers, writers you love who write beautifully and have made a great deal of money, and not one of them sits down routinely feeling wildly enthusiastic and confident. Not one of them writes elegant first drafts.

But it’s still hard to believe.

As a circus performer, I spent hours in the gym falling into mats over and over again, watching people I loved and respected, people I knew to be far more skilled than me, also fall into mats over and over again in the same room. In a museum, I can see Picasso’s sketches and mistakes hung next to his masterworks. But once a writer’s no longer in school, we rarely see the process of our peers. (If you’re still in school, start planning who you’re going to stay in touch with to share work.) I’m lucky to have a few writing buddies I can share shapeless early drafts with, people I know will be sensitive to whether I need encouragement or critique, people whose early and middle and final drafts I see, too, so it feels like an exchange instead of judgement.

Shitty first drafts aren’t the only way to write. Some writers prefer revising as they go. I’m sure some writers think through their story so thoroughly in their heads, or outline so precisely, that once they sit down, the right words come out in more or less the right order. But for many of us, the first draft is basically telling the story to ourselves. Thinking on the page–finding the heart of the story way down on page five, a single beautiful sentence in the margin, or the perfect opening in the final paragraph.

As a teacher, it’s embarrassing to share a terrible, misguided, overwritten, overwrought first draft with our students. As a writer, no-one wants to let our weak sentences out into the world before we’ve muscled them up and trimmed them down. But there’s value in a a sloppy, disorganized, poorly written first draft. It’s not a failure, it’s a necessary first step. It’s barre exercises before ballet, scales before singing, charcoal on newsprint before oil on canvas. It’s writing a 1500-word narrative essay/journal entry that becomes a 700-word hermit-crab essay. Taking the time to assemble the materials of events, characters, plot and themes, letting them be jumbled until they tell us what they want to say, trusting that from the pile of pieces we can find a story, we can pull a shining thread.

Yes, Virginia, wherever there are writers, there are shitty first drafts. And just as presents and nibbled cookies prove Santa showed up in the night, the very existence of finished, glorious work means someone, somewhere, wrote a terrible first draft.

Allison K Williams is Brevity’s Social Media Editor and the author of Seven Drafts: Self-Edit Like a Pro from Blank Page to Book. Want writing news, events, and upcoming webinars? Join the A-List!

Tagged: , , , , , ,

§ 17 Responses to Yes, Virginia, There Is A Sh*tty First Draft

  • My shitty first drafts are most often followed by worse. Only then, if I have faith and keep pushing, does anything get better. I recall the same experience as a visual artist—the Period of Black Despair, I called it. With many years of experience, the only change was certainty that if I persisted, the project might become better.

  • Great article, thx for sharing 👏👏

  • Nice informative blog. Really this information useful for beginners, in this blog you providing lot of tips.

  • Joanne says:

    Needed this today. Have been feeling what Jan Priddy called “the period of black despair” about my memoir-in-progress for quite some time now. What I take from this essay, and from the comments above, is “this too shall pass” (one hopes, anyway).

    I have shared shitty first drafts with students. It’s good for letting them know they are not alone, and that with continued revision, even shitty drafts can turn into something pleasing if not beautiful. But it is admittedly uncomfortable sometimes…but as a wise writing teacher once told me, if you don’t take risks, why should they?

    Strong piece, Allison. Thank you.

  • equipsblog says:

    The one ‘universal’ truth I had learned over several decades is that the better I think the draft is, the more revision it will need. Next lesson is when is enough revision actually enough…. Great piece.

  • Steph Barton says:

    I was just having this talk with a writer friend the other night. I feel a certain pride that I can accept that the first (few) drafts will be shitty. Feels like growing up a little about process — now I don’t agonize over that first page and get nowhere.

  • lyndatalady says:

    As a college student, it was really nice to read this perspective. I always thought that I would get past the “shitty first draft” stage once I became a good enough writer. It’s comforting to know that my belief is not true! It takes a lot of pressure off of me.

  • John Aase says:

    There is something really comforting in realizing that everyone else fails spectacularly in their first drafts too. Sometimes they might not be total failures, maybe some of them are only the writing equivalent of stumbling down a flight of stairs, but most of the time they are train wrecks that make you want to bury them in a place no one can ever find. It is nice to know that even great writers don’t create prefect pieces their first try.

  • So needed this before inputting edits this morning to a shitty first draft but your line about “letting them be jumbled until they tell us what they want us to say” – oh yeah. Thanks.

  • […] So I am especially grateful to folks like Allison K. Williams, Brevity’s Social Media Editor who posts often on Brevity’s blog. I love every word she’s written lately, all of them wise: on getting down to the work, on celebrating tiny successes, and yesterday’s post on first drafts. […]

  • Maggie Smith says:

    Just once I’d like a novelist to post their shitty first draft of a first chapter alongside what was finally published, just to have a real life example to read. Or a conference presentation where there’s a comparison of 5-6 paragraphs in the original draft and the final product. (or perhaps even iterations in between as to how you got there)

  • I feel compelled to revise as I write and it drives me crazy as it’s so painstaking. It’s easy to get demoralized when hours of concentration yields four paragraphs.
    I need to try this. Thanks for sharing!

  • Lara/Trace says:

    Allison, you rocked this.

  • Reblogged this on Notes from An Alien and commented:
    Yes, it appears most writers’ first drafts need lots of work; yet, today’s re-blog author says: “…there’s value in a sloppy, disorganized, poorly written first draft. It’s not a failure, it’s a necessary first step.”

    Read on 🙂

  • […] Yes, Virginia, There Is A Sh*tty First Draft […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

What’s this?

You are currently reading Yes, Virginia, There Is A Sh*tty First Draft at BREVITY's Nonfiction Blog.


%d bloggers like this: